Whether you’re walking into a major bank or sitting down with a mortgage broker, it’s important to remember one thing: mortgage professionals are not all created equal. Much like any other industry, there are superstars who live for their clients’ success, and there are those who are just in it for themselves. Sometimes it’s easy to tell if a broker has your best interests at heart, but other times, the red flags are buried under a smooth sales pitch.
If you choose a professional based on the lowest quoted rate alone, you’re taking a big chance with your money. You might just end up with someone who isn’t at the top of their game… which can cost you thousands in the long run. What looks good on paper may not be the most cost-effective long-term solution.
Regardless of whether you’re dealing with a broker or your bank, here are 9 key points to help you identify a quality mortgage professional versus a bad one.
1. The “Bait and Switch” vs. Realistic Expectations
A bad pro may quote an impossibly low rate just to get you in the door, only to come back later with a higher one upon approval. I’ve seen this happen time and time again. They quote a rate that they ‘think’ they can get. Then drag the process out for weeks, only to come back with a higher rate. Even during the busiest of times, it shouldn’t take longer than a week to get confirmation of your rate. In most cases, it’s within a few days, if not, right out of the gate.
A quality mortgage professional gives you a realistic expectation from day one. They’ll either give you the exact rate or a narrow range (usually within 0.10%) if they need to request special pricing from the bank.
2. Painting a Rosy Picture
Some mortgage pros may tell you what you want to hear rather than what you need to know. For example, they might tell you that you’ll qualify for a loan when it’s clear you won’t. Or they may over inflate the possibility of your approval, getting your hopes up unnecessarily. They may tell you that you qualify for a specific amount, only to come back with a much lower approved amount.
In my book, Beat the Bank – How to Win the Mortgage Game in Canada, I tell the story of when I applied for my first mortgage… long before I was in this industry. A major bank told me I was preapproved for $320,000 and issued me a certificate reflecting exactly that. I was skeptical, and upon pressing them further, it turned out that I didn’t qualify for anything at all.
A good broker will be upfront about potential hurdles, managing your expectations, so you aren’t met with a crushing “no” three weeks into the process.
3. Skipping the Paperwork Early On
A huge red flag is a broker who submits your application without doing a detailed review of your documents first. This leads to false expectations and last-minute “surprises” that can tank a deal. Or could result in additional documentation requests in the 11th hour.
A quality mortgage professional will Scrutinize your documents immediately upon receipt. The income a mortgage applicant discloses on their application is not necessarily the income the lender will accept.
More times than not, we need to adjust the income inputted on a client’s application once we have reviewed their documents. We may need to use a lower amount based on the documents provided, or we may be able to use a higher amount. In either case, this can have a big impact on the maximum approved amount.
4. Communication (or Lack Thereof)
If it takes days to get a response to a simple email, you’re working with someone who isn’t serious about your experience. Similarly, if they never keep you posted on your application status, then you’re left stressed and in the dark.
A true mortgage professional cares about your experience and will ensure you’re communicated with promptly and proactively. They tell you your file is approved (or declined) the moment they receive the word from the lender and they keep you in the loop every step of the way. Emails are responded to promptly, with questions answered clearly and professionally.
There is nothing more stressful than an unreachable mortgage professional when your closing date is fast approaching. At PMT, we believe you should never have to chase us for an update. We provide proactive status reports every step of the way. Plus, we utilize a team-based approach: even if your primary contact is away, a qualified team member who knows your file is always available to ensure seamless communication and the high-quality service you expect.
5. Knowledge Gaps and “Guesswork”
If a broker constantly needs to ‘get back to you’ with answers to basic questions, it’s a red flag for inexperience. Even worse is the broker who fakes an answer to avoid looking uninformed. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve had to correct bad advice given by other mortgage specialists regarding early breakout penalties, prepayment privileges, hidden clauses, or other terms and conditions associated with a mortgage. Some may be completely off in their explanations or may be trying to explain something that they don’t fully understand themselves
6. Passive vs. Active Management
Many brokers say they monitor rates for you, but this doesn’t mean they are taking this seriously.
Securing a mortgage approval ensures your rate is locked in, therefore protecting you against potential increases. But if rates drop, then your rate can often be lowered accordingly if market rates fall before your closing date.
Maximizing your savings on a mortgage is something a good broker will take seriously. They will actively monitor rates for you to ensure you’re getting the lowest rate possible at time of closing. At PMT, we have systems in place to actively monitor rates for our clients. We’re regularly getting rates dropped, sometimes just days before closing.
7. Following Through to the Finish Line
On real estate purchases, lawyers may contact the mortgage pro before closing. A bad broker waits for that call. A good broker reaches out to the lawyer well in advance to ensure they have everything they need so there are no delays on closing day. This helps with a smooth closing and helps to eliminate any potential last-minute complications.
8. Pushing One Lender or One Product
A key benefit to using a mortgage broker is that we have access to multiple lenders. In some cases, a one lender may be a better fit for a client than another. It could be due to a lower rate or could be related to differences in terms and conditions.
In some situations, the rate may be attractive, but the terms may not support the borrowers long term goals. This could result in additional costs or higher than expected penalties down the road.
Contrary to popular belief, rate is not the most important component in determining the most cost-effective product as the real cost can be found in the terms. A good broker understands this and can explain why one mortgage product might be a better fit for your needs than another. A bad broker may not even understand the terms and conditions themselves, let alone, advise you of the risks and additional costs involved with choosing that product.
If a broker pushes every client toward the same lender or a specific product, they might be chasing a volume bonus or higher commission rather than the best terms for you.
Always be conscious of this. If it seems that they are particularly aggressive in pushing a certain product, this is a key indicator that they may not have your best interests in mind.
A good broker will actively comb the market, continually sourcing out the lenders who are offering the hottest rates. At PMT, our top 3 lenders can change year to year based solely on who is being the most competitive for our clients. If a lender wants us to continually send them business, then they need to be sharp with their rates.
9. Misdiagnosing Your “Grade”
If you have a more complex file, an inexperienced broker might put you with a high-interest “B” lender or a private lender because they don’t understand the specialty programs that would have qualified you for an “A” lender (like a major bank) at a much lower rate. That said, there are times where alternative lenders may be your only options. But there are times when we’ll see a file that was placed with an alternative lender at a higher rate, when that same file would have qualified through am “A” lender at a much lower rate.
A good broker understands various speciality mortgage products available, and which ones may apply to your specific situation. While it may not qualify through one “A” lender, another may happily approve you under one of their speciality products. A good broker will be able to determine the nuisances of your situation and find the lender best suited for your file.
Final Thoughts
At the end of the day, a quality mortgage professional will advise you against their own best interests if it’s the right move for you. At PMT, we do this regularly as we believe in building “clients for life.” It’s why more than 90% of our business comes from repeat clients and referrals.
Whether you’re working with a mortgage broker or a bank mortgage specialist, do your homework:
- Google them: Look for real reviews. A long list of reviews will give you a reasonable expectation on what it will be like working with them.
- LinkedIn them: See how long they’ve actually been in the industry. For all you know, you could be taking financial advice from someone who started three weeks ago.
Choosing the wrong professional can be a costly mistake, no matter how “low” the rate they quoted you seemed at the start. A mortgage is a huge financial decision and should not be trusted to just anyone. It’s great to get a nice, shiny low rate, but that doesn’t mean it’s the right fit for you. Nor should it be your sole determining factor in choosing a mortgage professional. This applies equally to both the bank and the broker side. Unfortunately, many people in this industry are simply order takers. There is a big difference between someone who looks at their role as just another job, vs. a true mortgage professional who takes the quality of their work and advice seriously.





Leave A Comment